1 of 13
Could be better.
I chose this knife because I have a similar clasp knife, bought when I was a Boy Scout many decades ago. On the plus side, it does feel like that old heavy duty Scout's clasp knife - weighty and solid. It feels as if it could 'do the business'. I am sure that it will, eventually.
However, the details let it down.
The shackle is distorted which means that it cannot pivot freely on the rivet.
There is no nail mark on the main blade. (The tin opener blade has one, but not the main blade.) So, the main blade relies on the user pinching the blade to pull it open. Actually, this is quite easy when the knife is clean and dry, but would difficult with wet, cold or greasy fingers. A nail mark on the main blade would solve this problem.
The main blade only opens to approximately 170 degrees, the angle at which a non-locking blade is released for closing. It feels incomplete, unbalanced and although locked unsafe. It is not, but, as the workaday tool that it should be, it feels that way. Maybe this is a design feature but all my other folding knives open the full 180 degrees.
The locking mechanism is so stiff that pressing it down to close the blade requires padding between thumb and lever (I am a carpenter, my fingers are robust). Maybe this will ease with use? Perhaps. But it currently detracts from the desire to use it hence will it ever ease with use?
In comparison, my Mercator K55K folding pocket knife (also purchased from Woodlore) is a beautifully engineered and finished item. The shackle is straight and it pivots freely on the rivet. It has a nail mark to open the blade. The blade opens the full 180 degrees. The locking mechanism is efficient and simple to use.
One knife is the work of a craftsman, the other feels like the work of an apprentice.
Perhaps, I was just unfortunate.
Simon Levett
23rd July, 2024Rated: 3/5